CASL Penalties: What Canadian Small Businesses Need to Know

  • CASL penalties can reach a maximum of $10 million per violation for businesses and $1 million for individuals.
  • Fixing your consent and unsubscribe habits removes the most common CASL risks, since both show up in recent CRTC actions.
  • Directors, officers, and employers can be held personally or vicariously liable, but showing due diligence is a legal defence.
  • You typically have 30 days to pay or respond to a notice of violation, so read it closely and get legal advice.

Hitting send on a holiday email or promotional text shouldn’t come with the threat of a crippling fine. But if you’re emailing Canadian inboxes without verified consent or a working opt-out link, an innocent send can put you directly in regulatory crosshairs.

Under Canada’s Anti-Spam Legislation (CASL), the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) can impose steep administrative monetary penalties on businesses, charities, nonprofits, associations, and even foreign senders reaching into Canada. Most violations don’t come from malicious spammers; they happen during everyday small business operations. A local cafe sends a promo to an old customer spreadsheet, or a busy charity accidentally misses an unsubscribe request during a hectic fall campaign. Slips like these quickly turn into complaints, and the CRTC is actively enforcing the law in 2026.

Here is what your business needs to know about how CASL penalties are calculated, who can be held personally liable, what to do if you receive a formal notice, and the essential list habits that will keep your outreach fully compliant.

What are CASL penalties?

CASL penalties are civil administrative monetary penalties (AMPs) the CRTC can issue when someone breaks CASL. The law’s rules cover commercial electronic messages (CEMs), software installation, and message redirection. Under CASL’s penalty provisions, the maximum is $1,000,000 per violation for an individual and $10,000,000 per violation for a business or organization.

Those numbers are ceilings, and the law says a penalty’s purpose is to promote compliance and not to punish.

If you’re new to the law itself, start by learning what CASL requires.

Here are the terms you’ll see in CASL enforcement notices:

  • Administrative monetary penalty (AMP): This is the civil penalty the CRTC sets for a violation.
  • Per-violation maximums: The caps apply to each separate violation.
  • Notice of violation: This document sets out alleged violations and a proposed penalty.
  • Undertaking: This negotiated agreement with the CRTC often includes a monetary payment.
  • Civil, not criminal: The Act says a violation isn’t an offence.
  • Who enforces: The CRTC investigates complaints and issues CASL penalties.

CASL penalties are separate from your privacy duties under the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA). For that side, read how PIPEDA differs from CASL.

For a small business with 900 contacts, one careless send can reach hundreds of people who never agreed to hear from you.

What enforcement actions can the CRTC take?

Penalties are only one tool the CRTC uses, and most contact starts smaller. Knowing each step helps you respond calmly.

Warning letters

A warning letter is a formal reminder of your CASL obligations, without a penalty or a formal finding.

The CRTC sends one when it believes a business may be out of compliance, often after complaints.

Here are some example triggers:

  • A salon sends a monthly newsletter with no unsubscribe link.
  • A hardware store texts promotions to customers who never opted in.

Notices to produce and preservation demands

A notice to produce requires you to hand over documents, such as consent records. A preservation demand requires you to keep data intact during an investigation.

Both are investigative steps, and neither means the CRTC has found a violation. They show why records matter: You carry the burden of proving consent.

Here are some example requests:

  • The CRTC asks for your sign-up form wording and the dates contacts joined.
  • The CRTC asks for your unsubscribe logs for a set period.

Notices of violation and administrative monetary penalties

A notice of violation (NOV) sets out the alleged violations and usually includes a proposed AMP.

The CRTC issues an NOV when it believes violations happened. The amount depends on their severity, their number, and the factors covered later.

Here are some example violations that can lead to an NOV:

  • A boutique emails promotions to a purchased list.
  • A tutoring centre ignores unsubscribe requests for weeks.

Undertakings

An undertaking is a voluntary, negotiated agreement with the CRTC that often includes a monetary payment.

According to the CRTC’s October 2026 Pizza Hut undertaking, PH Canada Company (dba “Pizza Hut”) agreed to a $500,000 monetary payment over alleged CASL violations. The alleged violations were messages sent without consent, unsubscribes not honoured within 10 business days, and messages with no unsubscribe mechanism.

Those are the same basics a five-person shop has to get right. Here are some example undertaking conditions:

  • The business reviews and improves its compliance program.
  • The business makes sure third parties sending on its behalf follow CASL.

Undertakings are usually published, so a reputational cost comes with the payment.

How to lower your CASL penalty risk

Now for the good news: Most violations come from a handful of fixable habits. These five steps close the gaps that show up most often.

Ask for permission clearly at sign-up, and record when, where, and how each person agreed. Under CASL, you carry the burden of proving consent.

A Winnipeg yoga studio could add a sign-up form to its front desk tablet. Constant Contact website sign-up forms include the CASL information you need and keep a record of express consent in your account. Set one up with Canadian sign-up form tools.

Constant Contact’s study of 37,000 successful customers (April 2025) found that 53% of the most successful customers use sign-up forms. On average, those customers grow their lists by 1,000 subscribers a year. The form that protects you from CASL penalties can grow your list, too.

Treat implied consent as temporary. A purchase generally gives you 2 years, while an inquiry gives you 6 months.

For registered charities, a donation, volunteer work, or meeting attendance starts a 2-year window, and memberships work the same way. Once the window closes, you need fresh express consent.

A garden centre in Ottawa might send a re-permission email in month 20. Constant Contact contact exports show each contact’s permission status, opt-in date, and source. The “Confirm Subscription” template turns a click into documented express consent.

Step 3: Identify yourself and include a working unsubscribe in every message

Put your business name, mailing address, contact details, and a working unsubscribe in every commercial message. That includes the quick flash sale text you send from your phone.

Unsubscribe requests must take effect without delay and no later than 10 business days. These rules match two of the three alleged Pizza Hut violations.

Every email you send through Constant Contact includes sender identification, a mailing address, and an unsubscribe mechanism. See how those built-in CASL compliance features work.

Step 4: Hold agencies and third-party senders to the same rules

Who’s actually hitting send for you? CASL makes a business liable for agents acting within their authority, so an agency’s mistake can become yours.

Put your CASL expectations in writing, and keep copies of vendors’ consent records. If a Vancouver bike shop hires a freelancer for a holiday text campaign, the owner should make sure they know where all the phone numbers came from.

Step 5: Write down your compliance process

Write a one-page compliance policy, name one person who owns it, and train anyone who sends.

A short written policy and saved records may help you show due diligence, a legal defence we’ll cover below.

How to check your current CASL risk

Your risk depends on where your contacts came from, so no two lists look the same. A 20-year-old association list carries different risks than a new online shop’s list.

Could you prove how your last 10 subscribers joined your list? Pick 10 random contacts and confirm you can show how and when each one gave consent.

For each contact, check these four details:

  • Source: Note where the contact came from.
  • Date: Confirm when they joined.
  • Consent type: Check whether consent is express or implied.
  • Wording: Save a copy of what your form said.

If those details are scattered across spreadsheets, a few email list management habits can pull them together.

Test your unsubscribe process

Unsubscribe from your own email and text programs using a personal address and phone. Confirm it takes one or two steps and is processed well within 10 business days.

Old templates are a favourite hiding spot for broken links, especially in footers nobody has touched since opening day. Emails sent through Constant Contact include an unsubscribe mechanism, so focus your testing on other tools you send from.

Some contacts on your list may no longer have valid consent. Remove or re-permission anyone whose implied consent has expired or whose source you can’t verify. A smaller, permission-based list usually performs better because those people asked to hear from you.

Here’s how to clean out expired contacts without losing the ones who still want your emails.

Key CASL penalty guidelines for small businesses

Know these three rules before you hit send on your next campaign.

How the CRTC sets a penalty amount

Canada’s Anti-Spam Legislation lists the factors the CRTC must consider when setting a penalty. They include the violation’s nature and scope, your past violations and undertakings, and any financial benefit you gained.

The CRTC also weighs your ability to pay, any voluntary compensation, regulatory factors, and any other relevant factor. A business that slipped up once is assessed differently than a repeat spammer, but the maximums are still real.

According to the CRTC’s latest CASL enforcement report, the CRTC intends to take stronger enforcement measures when appropriate. Between 1 October 2025 and 31 March 2026, it issued 96 notices to produce and 11 warning or information letters.

Investigations are active right now, and your records are what you’ll be asked to show.

Who can be held liable

Can you be personally on the hook for your business’s emails? The CRTC’s CASL frequently asked questions confirm that directors, officers, and agents of a corporation can be liable.

That happens if they directed, authorized, assented to, acquiesced in, or participated in the violation. In plain terms, an owner who approves or goes along with a bad send can share the blame.

A business is also liable for employees acting within the scope of their job. If you use affiliate promoters, the CRTC says both you and the third party may be liable.

Due diligence is the defence: If you can show you took reasonable steps to prevent the violation, you must not be found liable. A written policy and saved records may help protect both the business and the owner.

What to do if you receive a notice of violation

Start with the deadline. A notice of violation gives you 30 days (or a longer period stated in the notice) to pay or make representations to the CRTC.

If you do neither, you’re deemed to have committed the violation. If you respond, the CRTC can impose, reduce, waive, or suspend the penalty. You can appeal its decision to the Federal Court of Appeal within 30 days.

Take these four actions as soon as a notice arrives:

  • Check the exact deadline on the notice.
  • Pull your consent and unsubscribe records.
  • Send all supporting documents with your first response.
  • Speak with a lawyer before you reply.

This article isn’t legal advice, so talk to a lawyer about your specific notice.

CASL compliance best practices

These six habits keep your penalty risk low:

  • Ask before you add: Add people only through sign-up sources you can document.
  • Save the proof: Keep the date, method, and form wording for every express consent.
  • Set expiry reminders for implied consent: Add a calendar reminder a few months before each window closes.
  • Make unsubscribing easy: Offer a one- or two-step unsubscribe in every email and text.
  • Process opt-outs right away: Act on requests without delay, and never past 10 business days.
  • Vet your vendors: Ask agencies and freelancers how they collect consent.

Each habit traces back to permission-based email marketing, the root fix for penalty risk.

Common CASL mistakes that lead to penalties

Most CASL slip-ups come from honest shortcuts, especially when you’re running everything yourself.

The mistake: You email a purchased or borrowed list.
How to fix it: Delete it and rebuild through your own sign-up forms, since you can’t prove consent someone else collected.

The mistake: You treat implied consent as permanent. It stings to hear, but a customer whose last purchase was three years ago is outside the 2-year window.
How to fix it: Send a re-permission email before each implied consent window closes.

The mistake: You assume CASL doesn’t apply because your business is outside Canada.
How to fix it: Follow CASL for Canadian contacts, because the CRTC says messages sent into Canada from another country must comply.

The mistake: You assume your registered charity is exempt from all CASL rules.
How to fix it: Remember the exemption covers only messages whose primary purpose is fundraising for the charity.

Keep your list compliant with Constant Contact

CASL penalties can reach a maximum of $10 million per violation for a business, which is a scary number for a small business — but getting consent, making sure your unsubscribe requests are handled promptly, and keeping good records prevent most of that risk.

Constant Contact sign-up forms record express consent, and every email includes your sender details and an automated unsubscribe link. When you’re ready, start your free 30-day Constant Contact trial and set up a compliant sign-up form to help you stay CASL-compliant.

FAQs

For consent scenarios like business cards and LinkedIn contacts, also see these answers to common CASL consent questions.

Can someone sue my business under CASL?

No, because the private right of action sections were repealed before they came into force. Enforcement runs through the CRTC and the agencies that share CASL responsibility.

Does CASL apply to businesses outside Canada?

Yes, if you’re sending commercial messages to people in Canada. The CRTC says commercial electronic messages sent to recipients in Canada from another country must comply with CASL.

Are registered charities exempt from CASL penalties?

They’re only partly exempt. A registered charity’s messages are exempt when their primary purpose is raising funds for the charity, but other commercial messages must follow CASL.

How long does the CRTC have to act on a CASL violation?

The CRTC can start a proceeding up to three years after the violation becomes known to its designated staff. That means an old campaign can still be investigated.

Share with your network
Avatar photo

Whitney Filloon is a writer, content strategist, and former Vox Media journalist who has worked with enterprise brands like Skype and Microsoft and helped dozens of small businesses figure out their "secret sauce".

Related Articles